Final test or Improved Learning?

Final or Formative Final

A student questioned the final in one of my courses. He said that he had self-assessed his work, he had made changes, I had assessed it, and he had made more changes, and now he was handing it in as the final. He was confident that he had done a good job; he really had done a great job. He questioned how it was a final if he knew what he was to do and if he and I had helped him to do a good job. He felt that those two things went against all he knew about finals. He never knew a final where he was allowed to improve and improve. He only knew of finals where he took finals where he guessed what was on the finals and then he received a grade. He also admitted this final was harder since he knew what he had to do, he could not fake it, and he knew that he had to show growth each time an assessment was done.

So what type final do you give?

About these ads

6 Responses to “Final test or Improved Learning?”


  1. 1 Steve Rosenbaum December 2, 2007 at 1:06 am

    I’ve given a few finals where I told students what the test questions were on the first day. There were broad questions that required a lot of work and thinking to answer completely. I don’t remember the actual questions but it might have been something as simple as “the plight of man” explain.

  2. 2 hgtuttle December 2, 2007 at 4:29 pm

    Steve,
    Giving the students the essay test questions in the first day of the unit is a great start. I think that to be formative we have to help them to do better so either we need to give them specific feedback or they get specific standards-based feedback from peers or themselves. Our goal is for them to be successful.
    Harry

  3. 3 Steve Rosenbaum December 2, 2007 at 5:29 pm

    I work in the corporate world and here’s a little something interesting about tests. (I don’t know the application to schools, but it’s interesting).

    It’s very common to see a disconnect between test scores and actual on the job performance. We often see people who do well on the tests that have difficulting on the job and vice-versa. So then I ask the question to the first line supervisors and managers, if you were to observe these people on the job could you tell if they’ve “got it.” Almost to a person, they’ll tell me they would know if 5 minutes.

    So I’ll say, why don’t we make that the test?

    As a result, we’ve replaced a lot of testing which is really a level 2 evaluation with a more structured evaluation which is a level 3 evaluation.

    We have a little different way of getting at level 4. We focus on measuring time to proficiency and the benefits of cutting that time. In the busines world it’s really significant.

    I think time to proficiency would be a great measure in schools. I think you could easily reducing k-12 to k-10 for at least 50% of the students. That’s a lot of extra money that could be freed up for other things. It would just require a little different funding mechanism than “butts in the seats.”

    If you want to see how we’ve done this in the business world, you can go to my blog at http://www.learningatlightspeed.wordpress.com or my website http://www.learningpathsinternational.com

  4. 4 hgtuttle December 3, 2007 at 3:27 pm

    Steve,
    Authentic Education has been a movement in education for years where students do real-life complex tasks. Students are not graded on knowing how to do a survey but how the analysis of their actual survey translates into a real action or change. Authentic Education believes that doing the task is the test. Technology can play a critical role in these real world tasks. Unfortunately, state tests do not value interdisciplinary higher level real-world tasks.
    Harry

  5. 5 Steve Rosenbaum December 3, 2007 at 9:55 pm

    My experience is that education is designed for the convenience of the instructor. Multiple choice topic specific tests are easy to write, administer and colate. I’m familiar with authentic education and it does a lot of things well, it’s just not the way things have always been done.

    In a corporate world, we’re more likely to do what works or what’s most cost effective rather than what doesn’t create waves. I heard Fred Smith founder of Fedex take about this same subject. He stated that government is so risk adverse that it can’t adapt and change as it needs to.


  1. 1 Final In the Course What is it really? « Education with Technology Harry G. Tuttle Trackback on May 1, 2012 at 12:26 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




RSS Education with Technology

  • Giving Students a Voice in App Selection January 8, 2014
    Traditionally, teachers research apps for their class. They assign apps to students.  The teachers assign a specific app or give students a choice of several pre-selected apps.  As a Modern Language teacher, I suggested apps to my students in the early part of the year. However, in January, I let my students select which apps […]
    hgtuttle
  • Considering Home Learning When Doing Mobile December 14, 2013
    Many schools are going mobile or one-to-one.  Schools sometimes make decisions without thinking about the full consequences such as mobile and home learning. If schools supply mobile devices to the students, do the students take the mobile devices home?   If students do not take the mobile device home, then mobile is only considered an […]
    hgtuttle
  • Good Apps vs Very Good Apps November 5, 2013
    Good mobile learning practice apps  facilitate and transform learning. Mobile learning activities can  increase students’ time on task.  In a classroom, a teacher calls on one student  after another but no student is active all the time; only those who are called on are active. Students remain  off task for much of the time since […]
    hgtuttle
  • Group Texting Programs: The Next Big Wave? October 10, 2013
    Group texting programs fall into two categories.  The first category consists of teacher- to-student text programs such as Reminder 101, . In these programs, the teacher sends out  text reminders, announcements, notes, etc. to the whole class with just a click of button. These programs are teacher -centered since the teacher pushes out information but […] […]
    hgtuttle
  • Assessment and Mobile Learning Questions September 10, 2013
    Technology can play a critical role in the learning process.  Here are some questions about assessment and mobile learning to think about as you plan for your mobile learning. Who/ What  will assess the students’ mobile learning? A) the same mobile app that the student worked on B) a  different mobile app C)  the teacher […]
    hgtuttle
  • How will students’ mobile device be used for learning? September 2, 2013
    How will the  students’ mobile device primarily be used? What other ways can teachers have students use mobile devices to engage in  learning? to introduce the learning goal to the students  before the teacher does in class  such as in a flipped classroom to introduce the learning goal during the class presentation to present alternative […]
    hgtuttle
  • Compare Institutional MLearning to Your School’s Mlearning August 5, 2013
    Many institutions use QR codes. At the Cornell Plantations at Cornell University (Ithaca, NY),  they have put QR codes next to many wild flowers.  When a person uses his/her smartphone to scan  the wild flower QR code, the person hears a poem that mentions that wild flower.  Even though the person is outside in the […]
    hgtuttle
  • Abundance or Deficit Thinking For Mobile Learning July 18, 2013
    Teachers and administrators think and act according to an abundance or deficit mentality. A few examples from mobile learning will explain the difference between the two ways of thinking and acting. In a deficit mentality, an educator  says the school does not provide mobile devices or that not all students have their own mobile device […]
    hgtuttle
  • A Protocol for Conference and Class Tweets July 9, 2013
    Conferences or educational events should develop a  protocol for tweets.  The conference can set up two twitter hashtags, one for social comments and one for content comments.  The social tweets  include references to the weather, the crowds, the excitement, the food, the desire to see a famous speaker,  how great a speaker is, where someone […]
    hgtuttle
  • Using a Mobile Device is Not Mobile Learning June 13, 2013
    Many schools are moving to “mobile learning” when, in fact, they really are moving toward using students using mobile devices. The students use mobile devices as they would have used a desktop or a laptop. Some characteristics of mobile learning (CLIP) Collaboration and Communication:  Students work with other students and adults in the class, in […]
    hgtuttle

Blog Stats

  • 637,015 hits

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 74 other followers

%d bloggers like this: